I think to resolve the seeming contradiction it should be noted that hunter-gatherers, who preceded the turnip-growers, did not run actual herds of animals. They let the herds run themselves, but grabbed a beastie or two every now and then. They would also eat a turnip sometimes, but wouldn’t actually grow the things, just take ‘em where they found ‘em.

I’ve long wondered why, compared to other “civilized” countries, the U.S is so bonkers, but I suppose we’re just young and ignorant, it seems.

I do think you and the “doubledome out of Harvard” are on to something here : )

As an aside, i must say – it is unfortunate such a sweet species as sheep is forever guilty by association with the gunners/guzzlers who used to shepherd them about..